Week 10: The Left Hand of Darkness


This may be my favorite book I’ve read yet for class this semester. I know Ursula K. Le Guin’s work from when I was a child, and I believe I read A Wizard of Earthsea around the time I was 8 or 10, though I don’t remember much except for the fact I liked it. The Left Hand of Darkness has a really interesting setup, since it has a familiar concept: an alien comes down to a planet as an emissary to space. Le Guin then messes with this premise until it becomes something fresh and unrecognizable. The alien is actually a human, and the planet is icy, with a culture based on snow and divided starkly between two major nations. Instead of a thriller, the alien’s arrival is all very businesslike, and he spends most of his time in politics trying to convince people to officially join the conjoined group of planets and peoples that he represents. Nobody really seems to listen to him, and he foresees it taking years to get the job done. The biggest divide between the emissary and the planet Winter is that the inhabitants of Winter have no sex – they live most of their lives androgynously, with short periods of being gendered in between, where they can have children as the male or the female. The emissary first finds himself repulsed by this idea, thinking that it resembles how animals go into season instead of being fertile year round, but as the book goes on, he warms up to the idea. He stops seeing everyone he meets strongly as a male or a female, and when his own people finally arrive, he is instead disgusted by how gendered they are. More important than these generalities though, it’s the specifics of our protagonist Genly Ai’s relationship with a person named Estraven that really made me like The Left Hand of Darkness. Le Guin takes her thought experiment and really fleshes it out into reality. Despite being from different planets, Genly Ai and Estraven eventually become friends and allies. Estraven helps Genly with his mission as an emissary, even to the point of severe danger. The two journey great distances and seem to get close to being more than friends, but ultimately the relationship stays platonic. Towards the end, Estraven gets himself killed by border guards in order to help Genly one last time with his mission. In this sense, Genly succeeds, but he’s left in mourning without his closest friend. It’s really a heartbreaking story, one which does an admirable job of throwing the concept of gender away without ever straying from its overarching narrative. Beyond even gender, the book has a lot to say about overcoming differences to forge friendships. No matter how different their peoples are, the alienation between Estraven and Genly fades away in the face of their growing bonds. The walls we build between ourselves here in our society seem insignificant in comparison, yet we seem often incapable of surmounting them.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 11: Johnny Mnemonic

I didn't have much time this week, so I read a short story instead of a book. Johnny Mnemonic was an interesting little read, and I think it did a pretty good job of covering the aspects of cyberpunk even in its limited span. We have the powerful femme fatale character saving the male protagonist, a nice reversal of roles which is common in cyberpunk. The woman is upgraded with some kind of cybernetic enhancements for fighting, as these types of cyberpunk women often are. I really liked the concepts within this short story, like the veteran dolphin who was hooked on drugs, the moving, pulsating killing floor where the story reaches its final battle, and the way “Johnny Mnemonic” himself was essentially selling his brain for encrypted storage protection. It was the nice blend of grimy underworld and futuristic technology that cyberpunk is often characterized with. The story wrapped up rather abruptly – following the defeat of the hitman, the protagonist quickly
Read more

Week 1: Frankenstein

It was interesting how this novel was laid out - at one point we have the monster's story as told by Frankenstein as told by the captain of the ship in his letters to his sister. This sort of framing device brings up some questions as to exactly how truthful the story is. Frankenstein may be an unreliable narrator, since he at least colors the description with his negative comments on the monster. I did like how we’re left at the end of the story to determine exactly who is most at fault – the monster himself, or the scientist who made him. It seems like every time the monster does something horrible, he has some valid reasons for being that way. Similarly, every time the novel begins to accuse Frankenstein of doing terrible things, the ship captain has some remarks on the beauty of Frankenstein’s character and soul. Over time we’ve sensationalized the horror of Frankenstein’s monster, turning him into a speechless, shambling
Read more

Week 13: Oryx and Crake

Blog Post 13: Oryx and Crake I’ve gotten halfway through Oryx and Crake, and I’m planning on finishing it over winter break. Margaret Atwood is of course an author I’ve heard of before, but strangely I’d never gotten around to reading any of her work until now. She has a really interesting approach to novels, a tonal blend of serious literature and science fiction that I can really get behind. Her writing is very internal, very introspective, which is the way I like my books. I’m the kind of person who’s always living somewhat in their own head, and Atwood’s writing seems to feel very comfortable and natural for me. Even though her character doesn’t share many attributes with me – I’m not a mentally disturbed man wandering around in a post-apocalyptic world where everything is hybridized from a variety of different genes – it feels like I can really understand the character’s mind. Atwood manages to talk about the most horrifying topics with a careful balance between
Read more